From the mid-1980s to the present, the middleclass of the U.S. has had their livelihood, savings, and future redirected to the ultra-wealthy. This was not an accident, nor was it inevitable. There was a slow pull from the top, camouflaged as “trickle-down” while it was really a large-scale transfer. Current “management” has pushed things so hard that people have actually noticed, potentially in time to reverse things. Apathy is still a very strong magnet.
How was this unraveling of the New Deal accomplished? I am not qualified to get into the finer details but there are others, here on substack, that are qualified. I work with broad strokes to help to understand the general flow and to facilitate discussion about the hows and whys of its occurrence and how it may be reversed if we have the will to do it.
The Heritage Foundation
No discussion of this subject can take place without acknowledgement of the active leadership of the Heritage Foundation. This “conservative” think-tank has been the core of logistics and movement. It was founded on February 16, 1973 during the period when Richard Nixon was in office. It was initially funded by the Coors family and then, later, by various “conservative” wealthy individuals and groups. It was likely initiated as a response to the Civil Rights Act and other social movements of the 1960s and early 1970s.
Working to reverse the New Deal, it encourages shifting the country away from democracy and towards an oligarchy/autocracy with the President as the de-facto executive figure at the public front (real control is “behind the curtain”). Moving us back to pre-New Deal, it focuses on pushing forth a white male supremacy, with power concentrated into a new, mostly “behind-the-scenes”, set of Robber Barons. Some social reforms are permitted to allow release of potential societal backlash as long as they are not seen as opposed to their primary goals. Although the official mission statement does not directly indicate a reversal of the New Deal, none of the above is contradictory to their stated goals and are, indeed, a variation in the vocabulary used in their mission statement.
It probably did not affect the time of Richard Nixon much but was able to “dig in” during the terms of Ronald Reagan. They create a Mandate for Leadership document which has been followed with an updated version for each Presidential (primarily Republican) term. It is believed that about 60% of Reagan’s proposals and directive originated from plans created by the Heritage Foundation. Most of the stack of Executive Directives (per Project 2025) signed by Donald Trump were written by the Foundation with detailed analysis of how they would encourage the goals and with methods of getting past the courts and existing laws. The Heritage Foundation also presents “appropriate” names for justices and Supreme Court Justices, based on ideology rather than competency, which the GOP can rubber-stamp. Conflict with the Constitution and the current laws makes use of delay tactics so the changes can start taking root before the courts determines their legality (often they are not).
The Heart of the New Deal to be Dissolved.
Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) instigated the New Deal to salvage the United States from the catastrophic effects of the Great Depression. In order to do such, he started the process of restraining the unregulated capitalism which was, in large part, responsible for the collapse of the Stock Market which cascaded into the Great Depression. He also (with input from Frances Perkins) instigated a social safety net which included Social Security, minimum wage, and curtailment of child labor and working hours. (They also started establishing safer working conditions.) They tried to create a national health insurance but the AMA was fully in opposition.
Note that a prerequisite of any reform is establishing enforceable ethics requirements for all three branches of government. Without such, enacting appropriate legislation will be difficult and enforcement would be impossible.
The path back, re-regulating capitalism
Getting capitalism back under control has various parts. These include restraining the use of money to purchase legislators, keeping regulations to enforce competitive corporate “playing fields”, establishing human culpability for illegal decisions, and requiring corporate boards to establish sane compensation packages for C-level executives.
Citizens United was a Supreme Court ruling that made corporations into unrestrained “citizens” with most rights and few responsibilities of sapient citizens of the U.S. This is absurd and must be overridden. I am not certain whether that would require only legislation or a Constitutional Amendment. With a sane Supreme Court, legislation should be sufficient.
The general equal-footing rational regulations of businesses needs to be restored. Antimonopoly laws need to be restored and/or enforced. I believe that most companies want to be ecologically sound and embrace a positive relationship with the community. But given the choice between being competitive and being a moral business, most will choose competitive. Regulations allow companies to do the “right” thing while still being competitive since everyone else has the same requirements.
Anti-monopoly, or pro-competition, laws need to be restored/enforced. There is supposed to be competition to benefit the companies and the consumers. It is being ignored (or, in the case of this administration, purchased) and even blessed. Bring them back. They never should have gone away.
Companies go to court. If found guilty they get a fine. Those fines may sound enormous but they are often (always?) a small percentage of the “bottom line” for a company. A company gets fined a quarter of their annual profit for a crime. An individual gets fined for the rest of their life. And, because it is just considered all part of doing business, the company has no incentive to stop breaking laws. The people making the decisions to do illegal things must be penalized with jail and/or individual fines. This may require rewriting incorporation laws but it is necessary.
Corporate boards see compensation packets as methods of competing for the “best” people. Those packets get larger and larger as they can do what they want. There must be limits. And those “golden parachutes” they offer basically say that the executives can do a terrible job and still get paid very well. What is the motivation behind that? Regulations can make it more reasonable and aid the distribution of that money back to the company, employees, and even stockholders.
Getting people employed again
There is a large group of people that say “if they aren’t working, they must be just lazy”. These are primarily older people who grew up during a different period of history when jobs could be had if you wanted them AND they would pay enough to live on. That is no longer the case and, with AI and automation, it may become worse and worse. We have three adult sons who have been applying, rarely even receiving an acknowledgement, thousands of times over the past two to three years.
There are many known reasons for this. There are probably some other reasons that are not well known. One of the big ones is that Human Resources (HR) (and automated gate systems) can only do one for one matching as they do not really understand the skills being evaluated. The job list says “C++” and the resume says “C#” and they toss it out as “no match” even though the two are very closely related and anyone who could program in one could, with very little help and references, easily work with the other language. Closely relevant skills do not count, when the HR person/gateway does not understand the job tasks, because they are unable to recognize the relevancy.
How can this be addressed? Split off the tasks for job application. The HR frontend is not able to match the skills needed to the skills given forth. But they can check degrees, references, job histories, and so forth. Then get those validated resumes in front of people who know the job tasks and can seriously evaluate qualifications. Stop having any sympathy for companies who say “we just can’t find anyone”. They aren’t really trying (and sometimes posted job openings don’t really exist).
The path back, restoring the safety net
There are various aspects of the safety net but they are all there to support people, and families, who have to keep living and no longer have a means within the financial system to do so.
Unemployment statistics indicate people who have been in the system, no longer are active in it, and aren’t finding a job. Two of my three adult sons are NOT unemployed because they have yet to get their first job. A lot of househusbands, and housewives, are not unemployed because they are doing vital work that does not get directly paid and are not part of the official GDP. Unemployment statistics indicate volatility in the job market — how many people had a job and don’t any more. If they are unemployed long enough they are no longer counted. My Russian professor joked that people were never unemployed in the old Soviet Union because unemployment was illegal.
Many people rely on unemployment checks but, as explained above, there are many more people who are not receiving income from the economic system than those counted in official unemployment statistics. Those people also need health support, food support, housing support, and so forth. Once again, as AI/automation, takes the place of people in the work force this segment of society will get larger and larger but the needs will not get less.
A proper safety net insures food, clothing, shelter, education, and health. Universal healthcare will help tremendously but the other needs cannot be neglected. Removing the caps on Social Security and Medicare payroll deductions will help to maintain solvency of those programs. Many “socialist” societies have systems set up to help people. They are examples of how this help can be structured. Perhaps the U.S. needs something different.
Once again, the “haves” say it is the unemployed person’s own fault but they say this only because they are employed within the system and don’t even count the number of people that they are supporting who are not directly paid (spouse, children, retired parents, …). If you count the TRUE number of people who are not directly receiving income from the economic society, they greatly outnumber (perhaps 2 or 3 times as many) the number of paid positions within society. A true living wage will allow those, who do have paid jobs, to support the greater number (spouse, children, pets) who do not have such a position.
The path back, decreasing income, and wealth, inequality
As mentioned above, a living wage allows those with jobs to support those without. Restraining corporate boards to compensate corporate executives’ at reasonable levels will loosen up belts for the companies to provide living wages and benefits.
Right now, in the U.S., there are graduated tax levels such that (in theory) people who make more money pay a higher percentage of income into taxes. Bullhocky. The richer that people are, the less income comes from earned income which is what is taxed at those rates. Once a person rises to the obscenely wealthy level, they may have no taxable earned income yet have a thousand dollars an hour earned FOR them by people whose work they control. There are various legal tricks, or loopholes, that the wealthy have had their legislators incorporate into the tax codes to allow them to get away with this.
How do we heal this discrepancy? Tax wealth rather than income. Income comes in as a person works. Wealth grows because of years of income exceeding the requirements of living. It has been said “the first million is hard work, the second is inevitable”. Perhaps we can have that tantalizing “flat rate” tax system imposed. Note that wealth is not always “liquid” — it cannot be used to pay taxes or expenses directly. (Some rich people do live off of loans against equity which does not show up as taxable, earned, income.) A low-income person has $50,000 accumulated wealth and is taxed at 5% (or $2,500). A high-accumulated person has $5,000,000 of accumulated wealth and is taxed at 5% (or $250,000).
Conclusion
The economic system in the U.S. is broken. Regulatory restraint must be reimposed on the corporations. Recognition of the true numbers of people not paid within the system is needed with ways to ensure that their living needs are met. Taxation of wealth rather than income provides a more equitable support of the needs of society.